So, instead of trying to find something to replace the very plain mirror, I dressed it up a bit.
At one time, whenever I went to a yard sale or estate sale, I would buy pretty beveled, flat mirrors. The kind that sit on a sideboard or dresser to add a bit of sparkle. Well, I though, why couldn't one of them dress up and add a bit of sparkle to the plain over-the-stove mirror?
A bit of heavy-duty glue, 24 hours of drying time and I now have a mirror with a little pizazz!
The second mirror adds a lot of interest and depth to the room now, shooting what is reflected in it in all sorts of directions.
Cooking is going to be so much more fun now.